Hey, I'm trying to make some form of scale so I can easily rate everyone fairly, instead of feeling. Currently what I have is. Full profile ( aka picture, bios, signature ) 0.5 point Proper introduction, which tells us something about the person 1 half introduction or crappy one liners 0.1 Makes threads with interesting debate 1 Rate on post quality in general ( vary 0 - 2 ) Contributes to the community, making members feel welcome, keep discussion going etc. 0.5 If person does not contribute to forum subject ( aka forum about pokemon and just talks about a youtube video and replies to coffee or tea thread ) -4 If I should follow that list, would that come to a fair rating ? Because I want a reliable system for myself. Hope you could give some feedback.