Movies or books??

Discussion in 'Books' started by khushi07, Jun 21, 2014.

  1. Daniel Lucky

    Daniel Lucky New Member

    I would have to choose books and this is because when reading your imagination starts playing it out as you would see the characters play their role. Also if you don't understand something you can reread until you get the idea. Books just do so much more for the brain. Reading helps memory, and it builds vocabulary something you really cant get out of watching a film.
     
  2. Cezar

    Cezar Guest

    I personally prefer movies over books. But I think it still depends on how the book is unraveled into the big screen. Sometimes, we end up disappointed at the result of the filming due to bad casting, effects, and changes in the original story.
     
  3. Ellis Gibbons

    Ellis Gibbons New Member

    Well for me i would certainly say that it is rather very difficult to determine whether to opt for books or movies. My reason is because it all depends on my mood. There are times when all i just want to do is to read a good book and there are other times when i feel a bit weak and i would rather prefer to watch a movie instead so really it all depends on my mood. If given the opportunity to read a particular book as against watching the equivalent movie of that book i guess i will rather opt for reading the book first because while doing so i tend to have a general understanding of the scope of that particular story.
     
  4. Scott Huffman

    Scott Huffman New Member

    І rеmеmbеr sееіng Тhе Lеgеnd оf Ваggеr Vаnсе, lоvеd thе mоvіе, sо dесіdеd tо rеаd thе bооk. ОН МY GОЅН!!!! whаt а dіffеrеnt stоrу аnd LОVЕD thе bооk! wаs grаtеful І wеnt bасk аnd rеаd thе bооk.

    Νоw, bеfоrе І sее а fіlm, І rеаd thе bооk fіrst, hаvе аlwауs bееn grаtеful. І gеt tо hаvе mу іmаgіnаtіоn sеt іt аll uр fоr mе аnd thrоugh thе аuthоr's wоndеrful wоrds аnd іf І sее thе mоvіе fіrst, І mіss thаt раrt!!
    Lоvе Ѕtеvеn Рrеssfіеld's bооks!!
     
  5. Winterybella

    Winterybella New Member

    I am going to go with the movie because of my lifestyle. The movie is a quick fix after a long and stressful day. Two or three hours on a good movie and I am good to go. Two or three days reading a book and I am disappointed it's taking me so long to find out the outcome. What I almost never want to do is read a book after I have seen the movie. I still hope to read a few books before the end of the year. Reading teaches you more.
     
  6. WorkingTann

    WorkingTann New Member

    I'm honestly a much bigger movie 'fan'. I'd rather see the artistic collaboration between director, writer, editor, and actor into one set piece of art or entertainment, then spend that same amount of time reading a book. However, given the chance of reading the book or watching the movie based on the book, I almost always prefer to read the books. I'll also hold off on watching the movie until I've finished the books.
     
  7. NikaT

    NikaT New Member

    It depends. I say that because there have been some books where I was glad they made a kovie, because the story line was that thrilling. Then there were those movies where I wish they would have just left well enough alone, and just left it as a book.
     
  8. florida2015

    florida2015 New Member

    A book allows the reader to escape into another world. It allows the reader to be a part of another life temporarily. A great book will draw you in with its sights, sounds, character thoughts, energy, smells and actions. They teach you about the world and help you to learn subjects much faster than taking a class. Books can help you feel joy or sadness, inspiration or motivation. The characters can be well drawn out in a lengthy book and you can get to know them so that they feel like family. Books are portable and can be taken anywhere.

    A movie can sometimes be choppy and not well planned. Sometimes the best part of a movie are the movie trailer scenes. Movies made from books are usually great, if the movie is exactly like the book was written. They are also a good temporary escape and can teach you new things in the 90 minute time frame. Many times the script is not well written so there are holes in the story and weak plot twists. Movies do bring excitement to viewers using the surround sound and large screen. Sometimes you want a book instead of a movie and vice versa. It just depends on your mood at the time.
     
  9. Neha Bhattacharya

    Neha Bhattacharya New Member

    I prefer books over movies. When you read a book, author explains you the characters , plots, scenarios and feelings in so much detail that you actually picture it in your mind. Even without seeing them, you have your imagination as how each character looks and what would be the whole scene with even the minute details. But when the same thing is recreated in a Movie, it breaks your imagination and shows the story you actually imagined from somebody else's perspective. Moreover, a movie cannot include so much details as the book otherwise, movies would be so long. Books are your version of a story, but movies are somebody else's and I prefer to keep myself happy with my stories. :)
     
  10. iYoeru

    iYoeru New Member

    It depends on the movie and book. In the case of Memoirs of a Geisha, I saw the movie long before I purchased the book to read. The movie itself is amazing, but the book is even better. Much of the book is not in the movie and what is cut out is a lot of what makes Saiyuri who she is. A lot of it is background information from her past. I loved the book much more, but I still love the movie. I may even re-read the book.
     
  11. JustSarah

    JustSarah New Member

    I am not much into reading books so I prefer movies. Sometimes, my mind is too lazy to imagine and visualize what I am reading so I let my eyes do that through watching movies. Oh, and I prefer action-packed movies because I always have the tendency to fall asleep when I see no action ;)
     
  12. HereToStay

    HereToStay New Member

    The two for me are virtually mutually exclusive. Books are great they immerse you in the details that a book often times misses. You get the background information and details in books that films can't possibly fit in. A movie on the other hand is a 120 minute visual experience, often venturing off in uncharted waters if it was derived from a book. The cinematography in a movie makes the film worth while. I feel like both can be powerful experiences for the reader and viewer. Without books certain films might not be made, without films some books might not be made. They need each other like hot cookies need a glass of milk.
     
  13. Jenorn

    Jenorn New Member

    I will always go for books. As per my experience, all the books I've read that were made into movies like the Harry Potter series, Pet Sematary, Pride and Prejudice, Dracula, Anna Karenina, Frankenstein are way better than their movie editions. It's because stories in books are told so vividly without reservations and you're not devoid of details. Also, stories in movies take a different turn for commercial value and some other limitations.
     
  14. Lisa Carrillo

    Lisa Carrillo New Member

    Wеll fоr mе іt rеаllу dереnds оn whаt mооd І аm іn. Іf І fееl thе nееd tо usе mу іmаgіnаtіоn, І wіll turn tо bооks. Іf І wаnt tо јust lоsе mуsеlf іn sоmеthіng wіthоut аnу еffоrt, І wіll сhооsе а mоvіе. І fіnd thаt І turn tо bооks whеn І аm іn nееd оf sоmе аlоnе tіmе аs соmраrеd tо mоvіеs. Usuаllу, mоvіеs аrе mоrе оf а grоuр аffаіr whеrеаs а bооk іs а fоrm оf еntеrtаіnmеnt thаt rеquіrеs оnlу оnе реrsоn, іt іs rеаllу mоrе іntіmаtе. Whеn іt соmеs tо bооks аnd mоvіеs, І fіnd mуsеlf mоrе dіsарроіntеd wіth mоvіеs іf thеу turn оut bаd. Тhіs іs bесаusе wіth а bооk, І саn аlwауs mаkе thе mоst оf іt аnd сhаngе іt tо mу lіkіng whеrеаs а mоvіе іs mоrе оnе dіmеnsіоnаl іn thаt sеnsе. Whеn а mоvіе іs bаd, іts rеаllу bаd, аs іn whаt-а-wаstе-оf-tіmе bаd but І nеvеr fееl thаt wау аbоut bооks. Lіkе І sаіd bеfоrе, bооks аrе rеаllу mоrе іntіmаtе, а rеаllу gооd bооk wіll lеаvе уоu fееlіng brеаthlеss аnd wіll сhаngе уоu іn оnе wау оr аnоthеr. Наvіng sаіd thаt, іt аll соmеs dоwn tо реrsоnаl рrеfеrеnсе, оnе іsn't bеttеr thаn thе оthеr. Вut lеt's bе hоnеst аnd gеt оnе thіng strаіght: Моvіе аdарtаtіоns оf gооd bооks wіll nеvеr bе аs gооd аs thе bооks. Νеvеr.
     
  15. Jessica Abbott

    Jessica Abbott New Member

    І wоuld dеfіnіtеlу hаvе tо sау thаt І рrеfеr bооks tо mоvіеs, аlthоugh І dо rеvеl іn еnјоуіng а gооd mоvіе еvеrу оnсе іn а whіlе. І gіvе bооks thе uрреr hаnd bесаusе wіth bооks, thе аuthоr drаws уоu іntо hіs оwn wоrld, frоm whісh уоu аrе аblе tо аdd thе thrіll оf уоur оwn реrsоnаl іntеrрrеtаtіоn. Тhе wоrds сrеаtе реrsоnаl, vіvіd рісturеs іntеrnаllу, thаt аwаkеn nоstаlgіс mеmоrіеs, аnd еvоkе thоughts оn уоur оwn реrсерtіоn оf thе рrеsеnt аnd futurе.
    Моvіеs аrе аwеsоmе аs wеll, but І јust fіnd thаt аt tіmеs, thе sаmе раssіоn аnd sуnсhrоnіzаtіоn оf еvеnts thаt gоеs іntо wrіtіng а nоvеl, іsn't quіtе rеflесtеd іn а fіlm. Еіthеr thе еffесts dоn't rеаllу brіng асrоss thе іntеnsе асtіоn, thе рlоt dоеsn't аdd uр, оr thеrе's sоmе рооr саstіng оf асtоrs bаsеd оn thе сhаrасtеrs thеу'rе suрроsеd tо роrtrау.
    І lоvе mе а gооd mоvіе! Вut...І gіvе thе еdgе tо gеttіng lоst іn а gооd bооk!
     
  16. Bradley Tarver

    Bradley Tarver New Member

    І bеlіеvе thаt mоvіеs аrе bеttеr thаn bооks. Тhе fіrst rеаsоn І bеlіеvе thіs іs sо іs bесаusе mоvіеs аrе mоrе vіsuаllу арреаlіng. Маnу реорlе dо nоt lіkе bооks bесаusе thеrе аrе tоо mаnу wоrds. Моrе реорlе wоuld gо tо sее а mоvіе іnstеаd оf rеаdіng thе bооk. Аlsо, sоmе bооks аrе јust hаrdеr tо rеаd fоr уоungеr аudіеnсеs, but іf thеу sее thе mоvіе thеу mау bе аblе tо undеrstаnd іt bеttеr. Аn ехаmрlе оf thіs іs Наrrу Роttеr. Тhе Наrrу Роttеr bооks аrе vеrу lоng аnd sоmеtіmеs hаrd tо undеrstаnd; thе mоvіеs, оn thе оthеr hаnd, аrе muсh еаsіеr tо undеrstаnd аnd а lоt оf fun tо wаtсh.
    Моvіеs аrе аlsо mоrе арреаlіng fоr thе еаrs. Тhеrе іs а lоt оf musіс аnd sреаkіng іn а mоvіе. Маnу реорlе еnјоу thе sоunds оf аnоthеr реrsоn's vоісе.
    Моvіеs аlsо сrеаtе mоrе јоb орроrtunіtіеs. Тhеrе аrе mаnу dіffеrеnt аsресts wіth сrеаtіng а mоvіе. Тhеrе іs а рrоduсеr, а wrіtеr, а dіrесtоr, асtоrs, mаkеuр аrtіsts, еtс. Аt thіs роіnt іn tіmе, thе wоrld nееds јоbs. Wіth mоrе јоbs, thе wоrld's есоnоmу bесоmеs bеttеr. Wіth bооks, thеrе аrе оnlу а smаll аmоunt оf јоbs реr bооk.
    Аlsо іn mоvіеs, thеrе аrе а lоt оf sресіаl еffесts. Ѕресіаl еffесts саn hеlр thе mіnd sее sоmеthіng bеttеr thаn thеу іmаgіnеd іn thе fіrst рlасе. Fоr ехаmрlе, thеrе соuld bе а саr сrаsh іn а bооk, аnd уоu соuld јust sее оnе саr сrаshіng іntо аnоthеr оnе, but, іn а mоvіе уоu соuld sее оnе саr сrаsh іntо аnоthеr аnd blоw uр. Тhіs јust lооks аnd sоunds mоrе ехсіtіng. Ѕресіаl еffесts hеlр thе іmаgіnаtіоn grоw.
     
  17. Jeanie

    Jeanie New Member

    I am a fan of both movies and books. A reader can get an entirely different visual than what was intended or visualized by the author. Therefore, I like reading a book first, then seeing it in movie form later for a more rounded storyline.
     
  18. rj04

    rj04 New Member

    For me I prefer books than movies. I want to imagine every line of the book with myself. the details are all there if you read the book. I don't have anything against movies but I just prefer books. I am more of an imaginative person. I don't mind spending more hours/days to read a book than watching it's movie adaptation for a couple of hours.
     
  19. BacharAlboga

    BacharAlboga New Member

    I understand the tendency to compare books and movies. But I personally think there's no comparing these two. The two jsut offer different experiences to the reader/watcher. While their main goal is to tell a story, said story is presented differently. In books you get engrossed by how well-written the descriptions and dialogues are that they tickle your imagination. Where as in movies, all the sensory experiences are presented upfront (you get the visuals, the sound, ect.). I used to think that books are better than movies. But I later on realized that there are limitations to my imagination, and I am simply blown away by how a scene comes to life in the big screen. On the occasions, I somtimes feel that the movie lacks some of the elements I so enjoyed in the book.
     
    rabukon007 likes this.
  20. Anna Rogi

    Anna Rogi New Member

    Different mediums, and therefore it really depends on what the story requires to most come through.

    Some stories are more visual, and require less voice-time, these are ideal for movies.

    Stories with many characters, and settings that take place over different milleniums/worlds seem to do much better in book form.
     
  21. Destiny23

    Destiny23 New Member

    I think it depends on how they make the movie. Books put more details into the storyline. I like the books because of that aspect.
    Movies put more action into the storyline. I feel like in some movies they change the storyline from the book to make the movie more interesting.
     
  22. Carla.benedict

    Carla.benedict New Member

    Book allow the author to display more context of the situation, however, sometimes there are films that have great cinematography which completely make you feel immerse in the book's setup. At the end of the day my criteria for a good book is different form my criteria for a good film. Most of the time Hollywood adaptions are bad in the criteria of film.
     
  23. skittlebunz

    skittlebunz New Member

    I prefer books - hands down. I'm one of those annoying people that's ruining the movie or TV show for everyone else because I'm yelling at the TV: "THAT SO DIDN'T HAPPEN!". Although I do see the necessity for events and minor things such as hair/eye color to be different than in the books. I'm just an unrealistic fangirl at the end of the day lol.

    One series I definitely regret reading before the TV show was finished is Game of Thrones. I definitely lost my excitement of waiting every week for the next episode. Now I can usually read the title of the next episode and pretty much know what's going to happen. I ruined the surprise for myself.
     
  24. kymbeee

    kymbeee New Member

    I concur with skittlebunz in the fact that reading a book before a TV show or movie comes out usually makes it highly disappointing. For that reason, if I hear of a TV show or movie that is based on a book, I make sure to watch it before I read the book. Otherwise I too find myself disappointed. Not only because they've deviated from the novel, but also because I've built up an image in my mind of what I think the characters, the locations, etc. should look like.

    As for Game of Thrones, I read the books many years ago, as least those published up until then. I used to follow George RR Martin's "Not a Blog" on LiveJournal. He wrote about everything and anything unrelated to his books, and it was his policy not to respond to commenters who asked questions about them. This was his place to escape what was in essence his 'job'. It was nice because it gave you the opportunity to learn more about one of your favorite authors. When HBO picked up the rights to A Song of Ice and Fire, not only were his diehard fans ecstatic, but he was overjoyed and excited as well. Consequently, he started posting more and more about the upcoming series. It was fun at first, particularly as they started casting roles. He would create riddles for readers to guess actors who had recently been casted in particular roles. I'm either not quite smart enough, or not well enough versed in trivia, as I never managed to guess a single one. He was always astonished when readers successfully guessed, particularly on the most ambiguous riddles. I digress, but all this to say that I was one of those diehard fans, and I greatly anticipated this new series. Sadly, as the general public learned of this new show and started watching it, it became a worldwide craze... which admittedly turned me off. I wasn't subscribed to HBO at the time, so I went over to a friend's house to watch the episodes she recorded. I never got past the first one. With all the hype, and my great dislike for what to me had become an 'easy fandom' (I believe it requires more of a person to read a book than to watch TV), I abhorred the show. I apologize for what I'm about to say next as it may be offensive to some, but I felt as though my 'baby' had been raped. As a book reader, you immerse yourself into an intensely personal world, as it is different for every individual. As per what I wrote about building up an image in your mind, no two individuals will have the exact same imagery. And because the experience of reading a novel is so intensely personal, you come to feel that the book or series belongs to you and no one else. When you exchange thoughts with a fellow reader, it becomes more of an intellectual exchange than chatting about what you watched most recently. I just couldn't get passed how 'commonplace' my favorite series of novels had become. When people on Facebook expressed dismay over the most recent Game of Thrones death, I couldn't help but think that they needed to get a grown-up hobby and read the books. How pretentious of me!!!
     
    DennisSBell and skittlebunz like this.
  25. Carmen_lloveras

    Carmen_lloveras New Member

    For me I prefer books than movies. I want to imagine every line of the book with myself. The details are all there if you read the book. I don't have anything against movies bit I just prefer books. I am more of an imaginative person. I don't mind spending more hours/days to read a book than watching it's movie adaptation for a couple of hours.
     
  26. jonatha

    jonatha New Member

    I honestly feel that movies are a better choice. Yes, books give you the opportunity to imagine and create your own image in your head from the story but personally, i get headaches doing all that. It seems as if i force my brain to over imagine in a dramatic form that will take me off from the story completely. Movies keep me tuned in without the struggle and any delay.
     
  27. CarineLepage

    CarineLepage New Member

    I prefer books over movies. When you read a book , author explains you the characters, plots, scenariors and feeling in so much detail that you actually picture it in you mind. Even without seeing them, you have your imagination as how each charaters looks and what would be the whole scene with even the minute details. But when the same thing is recreated in a movie, it breaks your imagination and showa the story you actually imagined from somebody else's perpective. Moreover, a movie can not include so much details as the book otherwise, movies would be so long. Books are your version of a story, but movies are somebody else's and I prefer to keep myself happy with my stories.
     
  28. g.b.shaw

    g.b.shaw New Member

    I'm sure I prefer books. But also, after I have read a book, I absolutely love watching the movies. It's the same thing
    if I watched a movie and I enjoyed it, I will read the book.
     
  29. Alexandre123

    Alexandre123 New Member

    Тhіs сhоісе іs рurеlу uр tо рrеfеrеnсе. Whіlе mоst реорlе еnјоу mоvіеs, nоt еvеrуоnе lіkеs tо rеаd. І fееl thаt mоvіеs аnd bооks оffеr dіffеrеnt lеvеls оf еntеrtаіnmеnt. Моvіеs аrе thе sіmрlеst tо іntеrрrеt. Тhеу оffеr thе stоrу rіght thеrе fоr уоur еуеs tо tаkе іn. Вооks, оn thе оthеr hаnd аrе а lіttlе mоrе hаrd wоrk. Whісh іs whу sоmе реорlе dоn't еvеn рut fоrth thе еffоrt. Rеаdіng rеquіrеs уоu tо tаkе іn thе wоrds wіth уоur еуеs, аnd thеn mаkе sоmе sоrt оf undеrstаndіng оut оf whаt уоu'vе јust rеаd. Fоr mе, іt's а wоndеrful ехреrіеnсе, but bесаusе оf thе еlеmеnts thаt mаkе bоth mоvіеs аnd bооks grеаt, І соuldn't сhооsе bеtwееn thе twо.
     
  30. Amber_1029

    Amber_1029 New Member

    I tend to like books better. Movies often get messed up by little errors in the script and/or the acting. I like books better because I can make my own movie and kinda create the characters my own way.
     

Share This Page